An audit could not confirm all hazards found in Basildon council homes were dealt with. The Ombudsman found maladministration 32 times in the year.

An independent audit of Basildon Council’s housing could not confirm that every hazard found in its homes had been dealt with. The auditors said they were “unable to quantify outstanding risk”.

The finding is in a report by Pennington Choices, which the council’s Housing Scrutiny Committee will consider on Wednesday 25 November. It made one critical recommendation, about how the council records and manages hazards.

The same meeting will look at a year of housing complaints. The Housing Ombudsman found maladministration 32 times in cases against the council in 2025/26.

What the audit found

The council commissioned the review after the Regulator of Social Housing gave it a C4 grade in April, the lowest a landlord can get. The audit took place in September and covered 11,790 housing assets.

Much of it was positive. The auditors found:

  • 95% of homes surveyed within the last five years
  • generally good-quality information on the condition of homes
  • strong expertise in the council’s stock condition team

The problem is what happens after a hazard is found. Hazards are rated under the Housing Health and Safety Rating System (HHSRS), which covers risks such as damp and mould, excess cold and falls. The audit says:

  • there was “no coordinated or organisation-wide approach” to managing hazards, even though the regulator had named this as a key issue in April
  • hazard records are removed from the council’s system once work is finished, so there is no complete audit trail
  • the spreadsheet used to track cases has gaps, and for many cases the outcome “could not be verified”
  • the form used to record hazards had not been updated for the revised national framework that came in this June

“As a result, we were unable to obtain sufficient evidence to confirm that all identified hazards had been appropriately managed and closed,” the auditors wrote.

What the council says

The council’s covering report says the review gives “reasonable assurance” over the quality of its data. It accepts that its hazard process “is reactive and heavily reliant on manual processes”.

It says it is rolling out a dedicated digital system for managing hazards, with extra staff under a new structure. An action plan for all 11 recommendations is being drawn up and will sit inside its Housing Regulatory Recovery Plan.

The 11 recommendations break down as follows:

Priority Number
Critical 1
High 6
Medium 3
Low 1

Complaints and the Ombudsman

The council’s housing complaints report for 2025/26 shows fewer complaints, but most still found some fault:

  • 759 complaints, down 19.5% from 943 the year before
  • 469 (61.8%) upheld in full or in part
  • 623 (82.1%) about housing property services, mainly repairs
  • 148 taken to the second stage by tenants unhappy with the first answer
  • 95.7% of first-stage and 94.0% of second-stage complaints answered on time

The Housing Ombudsman decided 19 cases involving the council in the year. They led to 44 findings, 32 of them maladministration. The Ombudsman made 69 orders and ordered or recommended £13,299 in compensation. The council says it met every order on time.

The full complaints report names damp, mould and disrepair as a growing risk. It notes repeat mould treatments and complaints from families living in rooms affected by mould.

What it means for you

  • If you rent from the council and have reported a hazard, such as damp, mould, a broken heater or a fall risk, keep your own record of when you reported it and what was done. The audit says the council’s records of closed cases are incomplete.
  • If a repair is not done, you can make a formal complaint. If you are still unhappy after the council’s second-stage answer, you can go to the Housing Ombudsman.
  • The committee meets in public at 7pm on 25 November. The agenda and papers are online.

Sources