Councillors voted 6-0 that they would have refused 910 homes at Foots Farm, Billericay. The developers' appeal goes to a public inquiry on 11 May 2027.

Basildon councillors have said they would have refused up to 910 homes on Green Belt farmland at Foots Farm, south of Billericay. They went against their own planning officers, who had recommended approval.

The decision is in the minutes of the Planning Committee of Tuesday 3 November, which the council published on Wednesday. The same meeting agreed the formal reason for refusing 175 homes off Tye Common Road, Little Burstead, and approved 16 homes west of Burstead Grange by four votes to three.

Why the vote is advisory

Councillors could not actually refuse Foots Farm. The developers had already appealed to the government because the council did not decide the application in time. The committee was asked to say what it would have decided. That becomes the council’s case at the appeal.

The council’s appeal record, 26/00050/NONDET, now shows the procedure as a public inquiry. It gives a start date of Tuesday 22 September and an appeal hearing date of Tuesday 11 May 2027, with the venue listed as the St Georges Suite. That is the meeting room at the Basildon Centre where the committee itself sits.

How the committee voted

Application Officers said Committee decided Vote (for, against, abstained)
Foots Farm, up to 910 homes (25/01466/OUT) Approve Would have refused 6, 0, 1
Tye Common Road, up to 175 homes (25/01214/OUT) Approve (October) Refusal wording agreed 5, 0, 2
West of Burstead Grange, 16 homes (26/00356/FULL) Approve Approved, subject to a Section 106 agreement 4, 3, 0

On Foots Farm, the committee first voted on the officers’ recommendation to approve. Nobody voted for it: six councillors voted against and one abstained. After an adjournment, the Vice-Chairman, Cllr Journet, proposed the refusal reason and the Chairman, Cllr Larkin, seconded it.

The reason councillors gave for Foots Farm

The minutes record one ground, built on Green Belt policy. The committee said:

  • the scheme is inappropriate development in the Green Belt
  • the site is not grey belt land and the scheme does not meet NPPF policy GB7
  • it would cause substantial harm to the openness of the Green Belt
  • it conflicts with three Green Belt purposes: checking the sprawl of large built-up areas, stopping neighbouring towns merging, and protecting the countryside from encroachment
  • it would lose 37.9 hectares of best and most versatile agricultural land
  • the benefits, on their own or together, do not clearly outweigh that harm

The scheme is therefore contrary to NPPF policies GB6, GB7, GB8 and N2, and saved policy BAS GB1 of the Basildon District Local Plan, the minutes say.

What the scheme offered

The application covers 56.9 hectares of farmland on the edge of Great Burstead. According to the minutes, it included:

  • up to 910 homes, half of them affordable
  • eight Gypsy and Traveller pitches
  • 3.44 hectares kept for a three-form entry primary school
  • a Section 106 package of more than £20 million, for education, healthcare, culture, play and sport, bus services, jobs and skills, and coastal wildlife mitigation

The officer told the meeting the benefits “significantly” outweighed the Green Belt harm, and that no statutory consultee had objected. Our report before the meeting sets out the officers’ case and the money in detail.

What councillors and objectors raised

Three residents and the chair of the parish council spoke against the scheme. Their points, as the minutes summarise them, included traffic on Coxes Farm Road, Bell Hill and nearby junctions, the loss of farmland, pressure on schools, GPs and the hospital, and access to the proposed traveller pitches.

Members asked about the proposed bus service. Officers said the planned northern bus route depends on a separate development coming forward, although buses and better stops would still be provided in and around the site. Improvements to Sun Corner would be secured through conditions and developer money, officers said.

Several members said it was hard to judge the scheme apart from the wider allocation it belongs to in the draft Local Plan. They questioned how much weight to give benefits that depend on other applications. Members also placed weight on the number of public objections and on the parish council’s representations.

The council’s legal adviser told the committee that doubts about the bus route could reduce the weight given to the benefits. On its own, the absence of the route would not be a reason for refusal. The adviser also said the fact the application had gone to appeal was not a material planning consideration.

Before the item, members complained that a technical briefing had been arranged without consulting the Chair and Vice-Chair. They said Essex County Council’s highways team had not been invited. The meeting agreed to try to secure highways representation at future meetings where roads are a major issue.

Tye Common Road: the refusal reason is now agreed

Councillors had voted against up to 175 homes on land west of Tye Common Road, Little Burstead, on 7 October. On 3 November they agreed the wording. Two councillors who had missed the October meeting did not vote.

The reason says the site makes a strong contribution to checking urban sprawl, so it is not grey belt. The scheme would cause substantial harm to openness, and its benefits do not amount to the very special circumstances needed. On Thursday the council’s planning register still listed the application as “Awaiting decision”, so the formal decision notice has not yet been issued.

16 homes west of Burstead Grange approved

The committee approved 16 homes on land west of Burstead Grange, off Church Street, by four votes to three. Officers judged the site to be grey belt, so the homes are not inappropriate development in the Green Belt.

The minutes record that:

  • half the homes, plots 9 to 16, would be affordable: six for affordable rent and two for shared ownership
  • developer contributions total just under £30,000 plus monitoring fees, for healthcare, open space, culture, play and sport, jobs and skills, and waste and recycling
  • no money towards education was sought
  • the access road would stay private and unadopted

Three residents spoke against it. They raised the setting of the Grade II listed building at Burstead Grange, road safety, access, drainage and the density of the scheme. The applicant’s community engagement consultant said local consultation had produced 22 letters of support.

Essex Fire and Rescue Service raised no objection. It strongly recommended parking restrictions so a parked car cannot block the access road. After a resident’s detailed representation, Essex County Council asked for a stricter drainage condition covering what happens if a pump fails or blocks.

Permission is granted only once the Section 106 agreement is signed. The planning register still showed the application as “Awaiting decision” on Thursday.

What it means for you

  • Foots Farm is now for a planning inspector. The council’s appeal record gives the inquiry date as Tuesday 11 May 2027. Inquiries are held in public. GOV.UK says written comments on an appeal are due within five weeks of its start date, which here was 22 September. Interested people can ask to speak at an inquiry, at the inspector’s discretion. GOV.UK explains how to comment on an appeal.
  • Tye Common Road can still go to appeal. The applicant can appeal a refusal to the Planning Inspectorate once the decision notice is issued.
  • Burstead Grange neighbours: the conditions, including the revised drainage condition 35, will be on the planning register when the decision notice is issued.

Sources